Education
Roth IRA Conversions Lost (some) Luster (Part 6)

Roth IRA Conversions (from Traditional IRAs) aren’t as much fun as they used to be, though this doesn’t negate their usefulness. In the good old days, starting in 1998, Roth IRA Conversions were limited to people with incomes under $100,000. Beginning with Tax Year 2010, the income limit was eliminated. Apparently, it took Congress that long to figure out that every Roth IRA Conversion resulted in more tax revenue in the year of Conversion. They love that feature; a buck in the hand, so to speak.
For many years, any amount could be converted before year-end with impunity, provided to taxpayers through a process called Recharacterization. When a taxpayer performed a Roth Conversion in one Tax Year, any portion of that Conversion could be undone before October 15th of the following year. This afforded the taxpayer (and his/her financial advisor and tax preparer) an opportunity to fine-tune taxable income from the year of the Conversion. The objective, of course, was to control the marginal tax bracket (the percentage paid on the next taxable dollar) of the taxpayer.
All good things, as the saying goes, must come to an end, and in 2018 that happened. No longer could we over-shoot the optimal conversion amount, only to correct it after year-end. We should note that the total amount of any Roth Conversion counts as part of taxable income. Unwanted income (above what the tax planning process aimed for) is taxed at the taxpayer’s marginal rate, having been irreversibly added to taxable income.
In the original OBBBA (One Big Beautiful Bill Act), income tax rates were lowered, and tax brackets were widened (both temporarily), resulting in significant tax cuts for most taxpayers. Unfortunately, OBBBA tax provisions were set to expire at the end of 2025. During the period of lower rates, Roth IRA Conversions were popular, as taxpayers would pay the reduced tax on any amount converted. This provided an incentive to perform Conversions.
When modifications to OBBBA were passed, temporary tax rates were made permanent. This provision took away some of the urgency to perform Roth IRA Conversions, as expected increased tax rates were eliminated from consideration. A future Congress may increase rates, but it takes time.
Another factor reducing the glitter of Roth IRA Conversions was postponement of Required Minimum Distribution Beginning Date for many taxpayers, from the longstanding 70-1/2 age to 72, 73, or 75, depending on year of birth. These taxpayers have more potential Conversion years.
These considerations did not destroy the value of performing Roth IRA Conversions, but the process has taken something of a back seat in financial planning. For all the right reasons.